bugmake - Bugs: bug #40725, Make could completely freeze...


bug #40725: Make could completely freeze during a parallel build in some particular conditions

Submitted by:  Florent Viard <fviard>
Submitted on:  Wed Nov 27 19:16:14 2013  
Severity: 3 - NormalItem Group: Bug
Status: DuplicatePrivacy: Public
Assigned to: NoneOpen/Closed: Closed
Component Version: 3.81Operating System: POSIX-Based
Fixed Release: NoneTriage Status: None

Add a New Comment (Rich MarkupRich Markup):

You are not logged in

Please log in, so followups can be emailed to you.


Sun Apr 10 19:31:11 2016, comment #2:

This has been fixed in the next release, by reworking the jobserver code to use pselect() where it's available. See bug #46261.

Paul D. Smith <psmith>
Project Administrator
Mon Jan 6 20:26:15 2014, comment #1:

I'm not sure what the rcmd*() stuff is here... is this part of the LD_PRELOAD provided by fakeroot?

In any event the POSIX standard clearly states that close(2) is entirely valid and completely safe to be called from a signal handler. For the list of async-signal-safe functions see the signal(7) man page on your system.

Although I've not looked in depth at this it seems to me that if fakeroot is replacing the close() system call with a version (via LD_PRELOAD) which is not async-signal-safe, then that's a problem with fakeroot.

Paul D. Smith <psmith>
Project Administrator
Wed Nov 27 19:16:14 2013, original submission:

I have a particular setup where I run make to build a simple package inside a using Scratchbox2, through a fakeroot, inside a chroot.
I wasn't able to reproduce this issue outside of this setup, but it is possible that is only a question of timing, the make running in my special setup being more slow.

In my case, I try to build an old version of "dosfstools" with "make -j 8".
The makefile is like that:
PREFIX = /usr/local
DOCDIR = $(PREFIX)/share/doc
MANDIR = $(PREFIX)/share/man

OPTFLAGS = -O2 -fomit-frame-pointer $(shell getconf LFS_CFLAGS)
WARNFLAGS = -Wall -Wextra -Wno-sign-compare -Wno-missing-field-initializers -Wmissing-prototypes -Wstrict-prototypes

VPATH = src

all: build

build: dosfsck dosfslabel mkdosfs

dosfsck: boot.o check.o common.o fat.o file.o io.o lfn.o dosfsck.o

dosfslabel: boot.o check.o common.o fat.o file.o io.o lfn.o dosfslabel.o

mkdosfs: mkdosfs.o


I don't notice this issue if I replace this line:
OPTFLAGS = -O2 -fomit-frame-pointer $(shell getconf LFS_CFLAGS)
by this one:

When make is frozen, I can see the following process tree:
... |-sh---fakeroot---sb2-monitor-+-bash---bash---make---qemu-arm
Basically, qemu-arm is what effectively run the "getconf" command.

The interesting point is that "qemu-arm" is in Zombie state.
So it has already completed but make havn't yet done a waitpid for it.

I did my work with Make 3.81, but I noticed no change to the following parts of code in last versions of Make.

Inside job.c, inside the new_job() function, there is the following piece of code inside a while loop:
/* Make sure we have a dup'd FD. */
if (job_rfd < 0)
DB (DB_JOBS, ("Duplicate the job FD\n"));
job_rfd = dup (job_fds[0]);


/* Reap anything that's currently waiting. */
reap_children (0, 0);

/* Kick off any jobs we have waiting for an opportunity that
can run now (i.e., waiting for load). */
start_waiting_jobs ();

/* If our "free" slot has become available, use it; we don't need an
actual token. */
if (!jobserver_tokens)

/* There must be at least one child already, or we have no business
waiting for a token. */
if (!children)
fatal (NILF, "INTERNAL: no children as we go to sleep on read\n");


/* Set interruptible system calls, and read() for a job token. */
set_child_handler_action_flags (1, waiting_jobs != NULL);
got_token = read (job_rfd, &token, 1);
saved_errno = errno;
set_child_handler_action_flags (0, waiting_jobs != NULL);

Basically, set_child_handler_action_flags() will enable restarting syscall in case of signal interruption before and disable it after the read
and it will also enable the following signal_handler for the rest of the execution of the process:

child_handler (int sig UNUSED)

if (job_rfd >= 0)
close (job_rfd);
job_rfd = -1;

The idea here is to be able to interrupt the blocking read if something happend to the child.

Later, if the process is able to acquire a "work slot", the shell command will be executed through "func_shell" function of "function.c".
(or "func_shell_base" function in Make4.0)

First pipedes pipe will be created, and the shell command run keeping the write side of the pipe.
Then, the make (parent) process do a blocking read of pipedes[0] (read side, child output),
until the child process complete.
for infinite:
EINTRLOOP (cc, read (pipedes[0], &buffer[i], maxlen - i));
if (cc <= 0)
buffer[i] = '\0';

/* Close the read side of the pipe. */
(void) close (pipedes[0]);

Here, the blocking read will use the fact that interrupted syscall are not automatically retried to be interrupted when the program receive any early SIGCHLD and not risk to be blocked for ever on the read.

So we arrive at the issue. Sometimes, make is frozen at the following "close" call:
(void) close (pipedes[0]);

But, if I put a "printf" just before the close, the issue is not reproducible.
Looking at gdb when make is stuck, I can see the following backtrace:

0xb76557c4 in accept () at ../sysdeps/unix/sysv/linux/i386/socket.S:57
57 in ../sysdeps/unix/sysv/linux/i386/socket.S
(gdb) bt
#0 0xb76557c4 in accept () at ../sysdeps/unix/sysv/linux/i386/socket.S:57
#1 0xb783cec8 in ?? ()
#2 0xb77648c6 in rcmd_af (ahost=0xb783cec8, rport=0, locuser=0x0, remuser=0x0, cmd=0xb780d8a9 "\201\303\377\340\002", fd2p=0xb783b9a8,
af=<value optimized out>) at rcmd.c:236
#3 0xb780d8da in ?? ()
#4 0xb780db1a in ?? ()
#5 0xb77fe415 in ?? ()
#6 0x08054430 in child_handler (sig=17) at job.c:436
#7 <signal handler called>
#8 0xb77648db in rcmd_af (ahost=0xb783cec8, rport=1, locuser=0x0, remuser=0xb783b9a8 "h\250\005", cmd=0xb780d919 "\201Ï\340\002", fd2p=0xb783b9a8,
af=<value optimized out>) at rcmd.c:286
#9 0xb780d949 in ?? ()
#10 0xb77fe415 in ?? ()
#11 0x0805106e in func_shell (o=0x949f849 "ssing-field-initializer", argv=0xbf93f560, funcname=0x8067158 "shell") at function.c:1737

It is maybe not really clear like that, but what happened is that we enter the close func to close pipedes[0] in #11, but during this execution, the "child_handler" signal handler is triggered because of the termination of the child subprocess. And inside this signal handler, as there is a value in "job_rfd" var, another close is called to close the file descriptor of the pipe identified by job_rfd.
So, make is there stuck trying to execute a close, inside the signal handler that was executed inside another close for another file descriptor.

So, I have 2 theories, 1) there is something not signal safe inside my libc or environment, 2) in my particular setup, environment produce often the correct timing to have the read that terminate because of the end of the input of the child process, and just then the SIGCHLD signal arrive just in the same time as the close function is called. (Bad luck :p)

Anyway, I think that there is something bad in the current code that should be fixed even if the issue is not really reproducible for different setup.
So, I have 2 proposal of solutions that works correctly for the current code in "job.c":

1) Always close job_rfd after the read, so the close in the signal handler will not be executed later than during this read call.
set_child_handler_action_flags (1, waiting_jobs != NULL);
got_token = read (job_rfd, &token, 1);
saved_errno = errno;
-> +if (job_rfd >= 0){
-> + close (job_rfd);
-> + job_rfd = -1;
-> +}
set_child_handler_action_flags (0, waiting_jobs != NULL);
( Because I don't know if it is really useful to try to preserve job_rfd for next iteration for not having to dup() again )

2) Add a new variable that will act like some kind of "lock" to be sure that in child_handler, the close will only be called during the interesting read call.
- child_handler (int sig UNUSED)
- {
- ++dead_children;
- if (job_rfd >= 0)
- {
- close (job_rfd);
- job_rfd = -1;
- }
- [...]
- }

+ int should_handler_close_rfd = 0;
+ child_handler (int sig UNUSED)
+ {
+ ++dead_children;
+ if (job_rfd >= 0 && should_handler_close_rfd == 1)
+ {
+ close (job_rfd);
+ job_rfd = -1;
+ }
+ [...]
+ }


/* Set interruptible system calls, and read() for a job token. */
- set_child_handler_action_flags (1, waiting_jobs != NULL);
- got_token = read (job_rfd, &token, 1);
- saved_errno = errno;
- set_child_handler_action_flags (0, waiting_jobs != NULL);

+ set_child_handler_action_flags (1, waiting_jobs != NULL);
+ should_handler_close_rfd = 1;
+ got_token = read (job_rfd, &token, 1);
+ saved_errno = errno;
+ should_handler_close_rfd = 0;
+ set_child_handler_action_flags (0, waiting_jobs != NULL);

(Option 2 is my favorite one)

In the hope that you will be able to understand my big bug report :-)

Florent Viard <fviard>


(Note: upload size limit is set to 16384 kB, after insertion of the required escape characters.)

Attach File(s):

No files currently attached


Depends on the following items: None found

Items that depend on this one: None found


Carbon-Copy List
  • -unavailable- added by psmith (Posted a comment)
  • -unavailable- added by fviard (Submitted the item)

    Do you think this task is very important?
    If so, you can click here to add your encouragement to it.
    This task has 0 encouragements so far.

    Only logged-in users can vote.


    Please enter the title of George Orwell's famous dystopian book (it's a date):



    Follow 2 latest changes.

    Date Changed By Updated Field Previous Value => Replaced By
    Sun Apr 10 19:31:11 2016psmithStatusNone=>Duplicate

    Back to the top

    Powered by Savane 3.1-cleanup