buggnubg - Bugs: bug #6532, bugs and suggestions gui export...

 
 

bug #6532: bugs and suggestions gui export analysis

Submitted by:  None
Submitted on:  Thu 13 Nov 2003 02:13:03 PM UTC  
 
Originator Name: Frank HaseleinOriginator Email: -unavailable-
Item Group: Other bugCategory: Graphical User Interface
Release: 0.14-develPrivacy: Public
Operating System: Windows 2000OS Type: None
Processor Type: NoneSeverity: 3 - Normal
Open/Closed: ClosedAssigned to: None
Priority: 5 - NormalStatus: Invalid

Add a New Comment(Rich Markup)
   

You are not logged in

Please log in, so followups can be emailed to you.

 

Thu 19 Feb 2004 03:20:44 PM UTC, comment #2:

Hi Frank,

Following on from Jørn's note, I've closed this bug report. Read my notes on your bugs/suggestions below (marked with >>). Please submit anything in the future in indiviual reports.

-------------------------------------------------

The GUI is very, very nice, so the 3D-board, although it crashes sometimes (minimize/maximize window is helpful in this case).

>> Try updating your graphics card driver.


Export of html-images doesn't work correct. I guess some images are not exported (e.g. b-roff-x0.png and b-loff-x0.png).

>> This should be fixed in the latest version.


The analysis window doesn't show GWC for checker play, even it's enabled (cube decision does). Only clipboard copy works.

>> I'll have a look at this


If a match with different player names is imported, GnuBG replaces the names which have been defined in the Settings/Players dialog although a new game/match/session is started. There should be a reset when starting a new match/game/session. Maybe a File/Close dialog is useful.

>> The player records will probably move to a database and this will be looked at then.


I don't know for what people the "Direction"-button might be useful, I would like to prefer some buttons concerning analysis (analyse match/game and statistics).Some kind of batch-analysis for several matches would be useful too.
Let's say import a *.txt file with names of match files and Gnu performs analysis automatically.

>> A analyse button may be added. I've recently added a python script to do batch analysis.


I'm missing some kind of hardcopy export for position including statistics. Postscript works nice, but statistics are not included. In the .txt export full statistics are included, but the board is somewhat ugly. Is it possible to create a special font with nicer board-design? Snowie used it for .rtf export (n.b. I don't use Snowie ;-).

>> Unlikely, why not use the html export?


Default name for saving files is date-players-match length. I would be useful to add a counter instead of match length, e.g. "2003-11-06-GnuBG-Frank-001.sgf" "...-098.sgf" etc. (usually you're playing more than one match a day ;-), or even default match file.....001.sgf.

>> I guess it's not that much of a problem as no-one else has mentioned it, just add your own counter to the filename.


I guess the rating comments (Awful!, Beginner, World class, etc.) should be adjusted. I analysed a 25pt match between Bill Robertie and Paul Magriel with GnuBG (world class setting) and both players where rated overall "advanced", whereas the rating for single games ranged from "Awful!" to "Supernatural" for both players!!!! (Did you ever tell them?)

>> Small games don't give an accurate rating guide.


In the Player Records is nothing recorded about the game/match statistics (e.g. games/matches won/lost ...percent etc.). Would be nice to have this stuff implemented (have a look at JellyFish perhaps).
By the way: If the player wants to add the match statistics and pushes the "Add to player records\game statistics" button by accident, and afterwards the correct "Add to player records\match statistics"-button, the game is recorded twice! Sometimes I don't know, if I'd add the match or not, and I think there's no way to find out (or even cancel). I guess this should happen automatically, if a player created an account before (known from Snowie).
The menu "Analyse\Add to player records" should be moved to the "Analyse\Match statistics"- window. Would be more comfortable for users.

>> The player records will probably move to a database and this will be looked at then.


What the hell is a Sho Sengoku Temperature Map? No. 34 at the Sushi Bar (rice included)?
Last not least, the German translation doesn't sound very smooth, in Germany we call something like that "Germish" or "Denglisch". Did you perform some kind of bot-translation? If you are interested, I could try to do some translation tuning for you, just tell me how it works.

>> Thanks for your remarks.


Jon

Jon Kinsey <Superfly_Jon>
Project Administrator
Sun 16 Nov 2003 09:30:41 AM UTC, comment #1:

Hi Frank,

Thx for your comments. However, we prefer to have one bug report per bug/request, since it makes it a lot easier to handle them.

Just a few comments:

(a) the html image problem is fixed in builds dated Nov 3 or later (ChangeLog 1.444+)
(b) you can read more about the temperature map at http://www46.pair.com/sengoku/TempMap/English/Intro_Map.html
or http://www.bkgm.com/gnu/AllAboutGNU.html#temperature_map

Jørn

Joern Thyssen <thyssen>
Project Administrator
Thu 13 Nov 2003 02:13:03 PM UTC, original submission:

Hi,

first of all: I like your Software very much and I'm using it since I heard about it nearly 2 years ago. After my first email dealing with some suggestions and bugs I was very surprised that some stuff was implemented a few days later :)).
At the moment I'm running 0.14-dev3D 1.440 03 1103 (build Nov 2003) with MS-Windows 98/-2000 (sorry for that :-)
Here are some bug reports and suggestions:
The GUI is very, very nice, so the 3D-board, although it crashes sometimes (minimize/maximize window is helpful in this case).
Export of html-images doesn't work correct. I guess some images are not exported (e.g. b-roff-x0.png and b-loff-x0.png).
The analysis window doesn't show GWC for checker play, even it's enabled (cube decision does). Only clipboard copy works.
If a match with different player names is imported, GnuBG replaces the names which have been defined in the Settings/Players dialog although a new game/match/session is started. There should be a reset when starting a new match/game/session. Maybe a File/Close dialog is useful.
I don't know for what people the "Direction"-button might be useful, I would like to prefer some buttons concerning analysis (analyse match/game and statistics).Some kind of batch-analysis for several matches would be useful too. Let's say import a *.txt file with names of match files and Gnu performs analysis automatically.
I'm missing some kind of hardcopy export for position including statistics. Postscript works nice, but statistics are not included. In the .txt export full statistics are included, but the board is somewhat ugly. Is it possible to create a special font with nicer board-design? Snowie used it for .rtf export (n.b. I don't use Snowie ;-).
Default name for saving files is date-players-match length. I would be useful to add a counter instead of match length, e.g. "2003-11-06-GnuBG-Frank-001.sgf" "...-098.sgf" etc. (usually you're playing more than one match a day ;-), or even default match file.....001.sgf.
I guess the rating comments (Awful!, Beginner, World class, etc.) should be adjusted. I analysed a 25pt match between Bill Robertie and Paul Magriel with GnuBG (world class setting) and both players where rated overall "advanced", whereas the rating for single games ranged from "Awful!" to "Supernatural" for both players!!!! (Did you ever tell them?)
In the Player Records is nothing recorded about the game/match statistics (e.g. games/matches won/lost ...percent etc.). Would be nice to have this stuff implemented (have a look at JellyFish perhaps).
By the way: If the player wants to add the match statistics and pushes the "Add to player records\game statistics" button by accident, and afterwards the correct "Add to player records\match statistics"-button, the game is recorded twice! Sometimes I don't know, if I'd add the match or not, and I think there's no way to find out (or even cancel). I guess this should happen automatically, if a player created an account before (known from Snowie).
The menu "Analyse\Add to player records" should be moved to the "Analyse\Match statistics"- window. Would be more comfortable for users.
What the hell is a Sho Sengoku Temperature Map? No. 34 at the Sushi Bar (rice included)?
Last not least, the German translation doesn't sound very smooth, in Germany we call something like that "Germish" or "Denglisch". Did you perform some kind of bot-translation? If you are interested, I could try to do some translation tuning for you, just tell me how it works.

Greeting from Germany and always good dice,
Frank

Anonymous

 

(Note: upload size limit is set to 16384 kB, after insertion of the required escape characters.)

Attach File(s):
   
   
Comment:
   

No files currently attached

 

Depends on the following items: None found

Items that depend on this one: None found

 

CC list is empty

 

Do you think this task is very important?
If so, you can click here to add your encouragement to it.
This task has 0 encouragements so far.

Only logged-in users can vote.

 

Please enter the title of George Orwell's famous dystopian book (it's a date):

 

 

Follow 3 latest changes.

Date Changed By Updated Field Previous Value => Replaced By
Tue 02 Mar 2004 11:22:28 AM UTCSuperfly_JonOpen/ClosedOpen=>Closed
  StatusNone=>Invalid
Thu 19 Feb 2004 03:20:44 PM UTCSuperfly_JonCarbon-Copy-=>Added fhasele --AT-- gwdg --DOT-- de

Back to the top


Powered by Savane 3.1-cleanup1